Resort and Resorts

I’m getting married this August and me and my fiance narrowed it down to these 2 destinations. Has anyone ever been to either island and which would you think would be more enjoyable to a couple aged 26 & 27? Both are all inclusive with the price being in the same range so its really a toss up. Based on the brochure the Bahamas seems more romantic and elegant and the resort is adults only, but my fiance thinks Turkes would be interesting as well. Before we put both in a hat & pick I figured i’d get some opinions first.